In October 1912, fifteen cents bought you a fat American pulp magazine containing an entire novel by a former pencil-sharpener salesman from Chicago. The novel was Tarzan of the Apes, the salesman was Edgar Rice Burroughs, and the magazine was The All-Story. Now the same magazine is going back to auction, and the fifteen cents is not going to cover it.
Heritage Auctions’ Pulp Magazines Signature Auction in Dallas runs on 4 and 5 December, and it includes two copies of the October 1912 All-Story. The first, lot 82001, is graded CGC GD+ 2.5 with cream to off-white pages. Heritage says only one unrestored copy has been graded higher. The second, lot 82027, is a restored bound volume from the Bob Barrett collection, signed by Burroughs and dated 23 August 1941. Neither carries a published estimate. When we looked, bidding stood at $5,750 on the graded copy and $1,000 on the signed one, which will look rather quaint once the room fills up.

Rarity is the whole point. Heritage’s own magazine, Intelligent Collector, quotes the Bookery’s Guide to Pulps as estimating that there are “probably fewer than 20 existing copies”. The same guide values a copy in GD 2.0 at $75,000. As File 770 noted, the sale also includes a full run of Tarzan’s second outing, the sequel serialised the following year, for anyone who wants to know what happened after the wedding. Pulp paper was cheap and acidic and was never meant to survive. That any of it is still around is a minor miracle of attics, damp-free cupboards and people who couldn’t bring themselves to throw a story away.
Recent prices suggest the room will fill. In June, Heritage sold a copy of the same issue graded CGC 2.0 for $58,560, according to Overstreet. That copy was a UK price variant, priced in sixpence for British readers, and it was the top lot in a pulp sale that took $1,864,073 in total. Heritage’s Sasha Fraze said at the time that “What makes this record-breaking auction especially impressive is that it was done without any six-figure books.” Collectors are clearly wondering whether December will produce the first.
It is worth remembering what this magazine started. Burroughs was paid a reported $700 for the novel. From that came more than twenty sequels, a newspaper strip, comics, dozens of films including Johnny Weissmuller’s yell, a Disney cartoon and a theme-park ride, plus the whole jungle-lord genre. Burroughs was already writing Barsoom by then, but Tarzan was the one that made him rich enough to buy a ranch in the San Fernando Valley, and the community that grew up there took the name Tarzana. It is still on the map. Very few authors have a postcode to show for their royalties.
For a magazine that has been online since 1991, there is a slightly uncomfortable lesson here. The pulps were disposable entertainment, printed on paper designed to fall apart, and they now sell for the price of a small house. One day somebody may pay a fortune for a 1990s web page. We will keep this one up just in case.
Bidding is open now on the Heritage site. Live bidding on the graded copy takes place on 4 December from 12 noon Central Time, which is 6pm in the UK. Vines, loincloths and yodelling are not required.
Sources: Heritage Auctions, Intelligent Collector, File 770 and Overstreet.

Join the conversation (0)