Decades of other worlds

What are you looking for?

NewsFantasy

Record-breaker in Britain, contraband in Utah: Sarah J. Maas’s Kingdom of Ash becomes the 45th book banned from every state school (book news).

Utah has banned Kingdom of Ash from all its public schools, the 45th title on the statewide list and the eighth by Sarah J. Maas.

Books · Fantasy
Cover of Kingdom of Ash by Sarah J. Maas, the final Throne of Glass novel
Kingdom of Ash by Sarah J. Maas (Bloomsbury).

Earlier this month Sarah J. Maas broke the UK record for adult fantasy, selling 188,914 copies of her new novel in five days. This week the state of Utah responded to the Maas phenomenon in its own way, by adding another of her books to the list of titles that may not be kept in any of its public schools.

The Salt Lake Tribune (via KPCW) and Fox 13 reported on 18 November that Kingdom of Ash, the 2018 novel that concludes the Throne of Glass series, is now the 45th book banned from every public school in the state. It is also the eighth Maas title on the list, which puts her comfortably ahead of everyone else and makes her, by some distance, the most prohibited fantasist in Utah. Five A Court of Thorns and Roses novels are already there, along with Empire of Storms and House of Earth and Blood, which was added in September.

The mechanism is the state’s 2024 sensitive materials law, HB 29. Parents can challenge books, and once three school districts, or two districts and five charter schools, have removed a title as “objective sensitive material”, it has to be taken out of every public school in Utah. Book Riot, which keeps count, found that a handful of the state’s 42 districts account for most of the removals, with Davis leading the field. The reports this week do not say which districts triggered Kingdom of Ash.

Cover of Kingdom of Ash by Sarah J. Maas, the final Throne of Glass novel
Kingdom of Ash by Sarah J. Maas (Bloomsbury).

Maas is not the only genre author on the list. As of Book Riot’s September count it also included Margaret Atwood’s Oryx and Crake and The Handmaid’s Tale graphic novel, Gregory Maguire’s Wicked, V.E. Schwab’s The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue, two Stephen King books and George R.R. Martin’s A Clash of Kings. Curiously, A Game of Thrones was not on it, so a Utah teenager can read the first book in the series but cannot find out what happens next in the school library. That is, to be fair, the experience Martin’s readers have been having since 2011.

Maas’s books are written for adults and do contain explicit sex, which is what these challenges usually cite, and parents are entitled to an opinion about what their children read. But the fantasy shelf has always attracted this sort of attention, from the American parents who tried to get Harry Potter out of school libraries for witchcraft to the long campaign against Philip Pullman. It is hard to think of a ban that has ever made a teenager less interested in a book. Given that Maas currently sells by the lorry-load, Utah’s real achievement may have been to give Kingdom of Ash the one thing it didn’t need: more publicity.

Sources: KPCW/Salt Lake Tribune, Fox 13, Book Riot.

Join the conversation (0)

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

×